JSP vs ASP vs Cold Fusion ??? - Page 3


DevX Home    Today's Headlines   Articles Archive   Tip Bank   Forums   

Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 123
Results 31 to 33 of 33

Thread: JSP vs ASP vs Cold Fusion ???

  1. #31
    Arto Santala Guest

    Re: JSP vs ASP vs Cold Fusion ???


    For development of jsp-pages you can use Jrun free licence version, or J2EE
    from Javasoft. Or TomCat from same place.

    Unfortunately, I agree that with Microsoft you can develop ASP and serve
    ASP on products without buying anything more than the NT server. With jsp
    you can develop for free - but I haven't found any free solutions for commercial
    robustness and business use yet. ASP could be thought as one, although you
    do have to buy Windows.

    I have no experience of non-windows asp platforms, but I've never heard of
    anyone using them in actual production either.

    >3) jsp servers ARE RARE species as yet now (hunting for whole good one month)
    >i haven't found a descent server that can be obtained as shareware or freeware
    >on which i can even BEGIN experimenting!! otoh PWS for win98\95 and IIS

    4.0
    >for NT and IIS 5.0 (fundoo server) with win2K (a really groundbreaking os)
    >comes bundled with their respective OSs and are perfect with asp.



  2. #32
    Gary Guest

    Re: JSP vs ASP vs Cold Fusion ???


    I agree with this. Writing too much script code on the page leads to limited
    resuse and very tough to maintain. I've seen this in both ASP and JSP.
    No matter what your server side processing technology is; COM, SSI, servlets;
    you should always stay away from page scripting unless you're building a
    small site.

    I still believe Microsoft and ASP are far more advanced at this time, for
    both simplicity and scalability. However, I do believe Java and JSP are
    gaining quickly. Since VB is not an proper OO language, your back end design
    is hindered because of this. And since COM is limited in it's design capabilities,
    Java is a far superior OO modelling language. Granted, with the changes
    to VB 7, it could be an exciting race. I think it all comes down to personal
    preference. It's a tough one to dispute.

    I'm not too familiar with CF, but from what I understand, it's a quick and
    dirty solution. Basically, for people building non-scalable sites.

    Gary

    "Sebasten Bouchet" <sebastien.bouchet@lycosmail.com> wrote:
    >
    >You have to analyse whch amount of extra service you need. If you want email
    >capabilities, ldap support, a naming service, platform-independant DB access
    >and growing XML support, then Java (J2EE)is a good think to look at.
    >
    >Then keep in mind that ASP runs best on Microsoft platforms (in spite of
    >Chili software), Java technologies on Unix machines, especially Solaris.
    >
    >But to me, both ASP and JSP (I don't know about CF) fail to separate business
    >logic from presentation by allowing web authors to embed far too much code
    >in their pages.
    >
    >I'm convinced that the only safe way to use JSP is too use them along with
    >servlets. The functional paradigm then becomes :
    >1) Intercept the client request with your servlet, process the data and

    business
    >logic (db access, online pricing ...)
    >2) Forward the results to your JSP which is clearly devoted to presentation
    >and presentation only, with JSP tags containing little code.
    >
    >By doing this your Java code is cleaner and can be as complex as you want
    >it to be (add exception handling to your JSP code and have a look at your
    >document in Dreamweaver ...)
    >
    >Hope this helps understanding what your needs are
    >
    >Sebastien



  3. #33
    Andrew Cooper Guest

    Re: JSP vs ASP vs Cold Fusion ???


    "Andi" <annops@hotmail.com> wrote:
    >
    >Hi All,
    >
    >Have anyone have an experience with ColdFusion? I read all your discussion.
    > I just only ASP vs JSP.
    >
    >Thank


    Asking which tool is better is like asking which ice cream flavor is better:
    It depends!

    We use both ASP and ColdFusion in our shop. Choosing a tool depends on what
    the client wants, what platform(s) the code will be running on, and which
    developers I have available for a project!

    ColdFusion is tag-based, so our HTML developers have really embraced it as
    something "close" to what they're used to. Our VB- and Access-experienced
    programmers prefer ASP (but they also "do" CF, so they're my "utility infielders").

    ColdFusion is really good for quick development of an application (we recently
    finished a 300+ module CF app in ~5wks), but ASP is better for more involved
    business logic and native (ADO) connections to SQL Server. ASP is better
    for more "traditional" programming styles, but CF is better for those not
    wanting to get bogged down in programming details. ASP is better for accessing
    files and folders on a server, while CF's CFCONTENT and CFFILE tags are draconian,
    to be kind.

    HTH,
    Andrew Cooper
    Partner/Chief Technologist
    Interactive Business Solutions, Inc.
    http://www.n2biz.com


Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
HTML5 Development Center
 
 
FAQ
Latest Articles
Java
.NET
XML
Database
Enterprise
Questions? Contact us.
C++
Web Development
Wireless
Latest Tips
Open Source


   Development Centers

   -- Android Development Center
   -- Cloud Development Project Center
   -- HTML5 Development Center
   -- Windows Mobile Development Center